| Part 1 | Part 2 | Next | Part 5 | Part 6 |
| Table of Contents |
"Is
there, currently, any set of criteria or symptoms that have been established as the
agreed-upon standard for diagnosing schizophrenia?" asked Rip.
"DSM-IV
is probably about as close as you'll get to a generally agreed-upon standard at the
present time," I replied. "However," I added, "these guidelines have a
variety of biases which shape and orient them.
"For
instance, DSM-IV is solidly rooted in a medical/biological model of human nature and
behavior. Moreover, this diagnostic tool also is, to a considerable degree, colored by a
Western cultural perspective in general and American clinical experience in
particular."
"As far
as this standard ...ahh, DSM-IV ... is concerned, what are some of the symptoms that are
generally believed to be associated with schizophrenia?" Rip inquired.
I reflected
for a few seconds and said: "One important factor would be the length of time for
which certain kinds of symptom have been persisting. Generally speaking, even when the
'right' sorts of symptom are present, if these symptoms have not been in evidence for at
least six months, the mental condition might not be diagnosed as schizophrenia.
"Instead,
if the symptoms have lasted for two weeks or less, then the condition might be considered
to be some sort of brief reactive psychosis that may have been precipitated by intense
stress of some kind. Or, if the symptoms have been present for more than two weeks, but
less than six months, then the condition might be treated as some form of what is known as
a 'schizophreniform disorder'.
"If the
symptoms have persisted for the requisite six month period, then there are about six, or
so, diagnostic categories which are compared to the symptoms being exhibited by the
individual. These categories encompass themes of thought, perception, attention, motor
behavior, emotion or affect, and life functioning.
"For
instance, there may be different kinds of disturbance in thinking that could be evidence
of the presence of schizophrenia. These disturbances may be either in the character of the
structure or forms which such thoughts assume, or these anomalies may concern the content
of such thoughts.
"In the
case of problems with the form of thought, the individual's ideas tend not to be connected
to one another, or the individual will have great difficulty sticking to any one topic.
Form-of-thought problems also could include such things as the individual's inclination to
use neologisms - that is, to make up words which may have meaning for the speaker, but
which, in all likelihood, have little, or no, meaning for the listener. The individual may
also make use of, what are known as, 'clang associations' in which lots of rhyming words
appear in the individual's day-to-day discourse.
"Disorders
in thought content could include a profound lack of appreciation for, or awareness of, the
existence of a serious problem of mental disturbance in oneself. The schizophrenic often
does not see anything wrong with the way he or she is behaving or performing.
"Another
kind of disorder in thought content concerns delusions of one sort or another. The
character of these delusions can vary considerably.
"Perhaps,
the classic form of schizophrenic delusion, at least in the popular literature, is the one
that is paranoid in nature. However, there are many other kinds of possible delusion.
"The
individual, for instance, may believe that someone is stealing his or her thoughts.
Alternatively, the person may believe that an external agency is broadcasting or inserting
thoughts, feelings and impulses into one's consciousness.
"Another
category of symptoms concerns various kinds of perceptual disorders. The most striking
symptom in this category are hallucinations in which the individual has a sensory
experience of some kind in the absence of any environmental stimulus.
"In
three-fourths of the cases, this kind of perceptual distortion comes in the form of
auditory hallucinations. The individual will report, for example, hearing different voices
arguing or commenting about various issues.
"There
are other kinds of perceptual distortions as well, besides these more common auditory
ones. Some people do have visual hallucinations. Others may experience sensations of
burning, electric tingling, or numbness. Still other individuals may feel that insects or
snakes are crawling around beneath their skins or in their abdomens.
"Another
category of mental disturbance that is used to try to diagnose the presence of
schizophrenia involves the phenomenological quality of an individual's awareness or
attention. Schizophrenics frequently report that the world seems unreal or colorless or
flat.
"In
addition, their awareness of the world may have a substantially alien quality to it, in
the sense that everything is experienced as being strange and unfamiliar. Or, the
individual may experience their engagement of the world in a depersonalized fashion, such
that the body seems to go about its business in the world in a mechanical fashion which is
devoid of a sense of personhood or identity as an individual.
"A
fourth category of symptoms revolves around motor activity. The schizophrenic individual
sometimes manifests, for extended periods of time, strange facial contortions, or they may
exhibit a complex, peculiar series of movements involving hands, fingers, arms and legs.
"Probably,
the most well-known examples of motor disturbance in schizophrenics are catatonic
immobility and catatonic agitation. In the former case, the individual tends to be, as the
term suggests, immobile and may assume various kinds of unusual and awkward postures that
are held for long periods of time.
"In the
case of catatonic agitation, the individual tends to be constantly on the go and in a very
excited state. In this condition, the individual expends tremendous amounts of energy with
little, or no, regard being given to whether an activity is important or unimportant.
"A
fifth category of symptoms which plays a role in helping to diagnose the schizophrenic
condition involves the character of an individual's affective or emotional engagement of
experience. In general, there are two distinguishing features to this affective component
in the lives of schizophrenics.
"Various
studies, such as the World Health Organization's International Pilot Study of
Schizophrenia, have shown that approximately two-thirds of all schizophrenics report or
exhibit virtually a total absence or flatness of affect in their daily lives. This
flatness may manifest itself as a deep-seated apathy concerning oneself and one's
surroundings, or it may show up as an inability or unwillingness to respond to any kind of
emotional stimulus from the human beings forming one's environment.
"Individuals
showing this kind of affective flatness will often be seen staring vacantly for long
periods of time. The muscles of their faces tend to be flaccid or loose and lacking
definition, and their eyes are lifeless. If they speak at all, their voices sound
toneless, mechanical and devoid of any emotion.
"The
other kind of affective disturbance that is prevalent in schizophrenics has to do with the
display of affect or emotion which is inappropriate to a given context or situation. The
individual might laugh uproariously when sadness or tears would be appropriate, or the
person might cry when happiness would be the usual or expected response.
"Much
more rarely, one may encounter individuals who display a constant, rapid shifting between,
or among, various emotional states. When this does occur, such a symptom often carries a
lot of weight with some people in reaching a diagnostic determination of schizophrenia.
"The
final category of symptoms that is considered in diagnosing schizophrenics concerns
disturbances in the way the individual goes about attending to their various needs of
life. These life-functioning skills would include things such as: personal hygiene and
grooming; an inclination to make friends and to socialize with other individuals; as well
as the capacity to hold a job or to deal with responsibilities in school.
"In my
opinion, this last category is somewhat more nebulous, subjective and less helpful than
some of the other categories of symptoms that I have mentioned. There are a lot of
different kinds of mental disturbance which would entail life-functioning problems very
similar to the ones that I have summarized and, therefore, don't necessarily provide a
good way to diagnostically identify the nature of the condition with which one is
confronted.
"In
fact, if one were to rely solely on this last category, then quite a few teenagers would
stand an excellent chance of being diagnosed as schizophrenic. On the other hand, when one
combines this category with the other five categories of symptoms, then considerations of
the quality of life-functioning sometimes helps to round out the general clinical picture
of schizophrenia."
| Part 1 | Part 2 | Next | Part 5 | Part 6 |
| Table of Contents |
|